📢 Publish Your Research for Free - Full APC Waiver, No Hidden Charges. Submit Your Article Today! Submit Now →
JImage

ARTICLE TYPE : REVIEW ARTICLE

Published on :   05 Nov 2026, Volume - 2
Journal Title :   WebLog Journal of Forensic Science and Criminology | WebLog J Forensic Sci Criminol | WJFSC
Journal ISSN:   3144-7384
Source URL:   weblog icon https://weblogoa.com/articles/wjfsc.2026.k0501
Permanent Identifier (DOI) :   doi icon https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24222938

The Criminal Mind Under the Forensic Lens: A Critical Narrative Review of Criminal Psychology, Criminology and Forensic Evidence

Satwik Chatterjee 1 *
Medha Chakraborty 1
1Postgraduate Student, Department of Forensic Science, School of Basic and Applied Sciences, Adamas University, Kolkata, West Bengal, India

Abstract

Understanding criminal behavior involves consideration of psychological processes and social circumstances and the physical traces a criminal offense leaves behind. This critical narrative review explores the interface of criminal psychology, criminology and forensic science with particular reference to the distinction between providing behavioral-based hypotheses for investigation and providing evidence-based proof of a criminal’s guilt. In order to achieve these objectives a range of scholarly papers and official scientific reports have been selected for review concerning topics such as developmental antisocial behavior, offense opportunity, offender profiling, mental disorder and offender behavior, confession evidence, and the reliability of various types of forensic evidence. Although it is possible to provide behavioral-based explanations of most criminal behavior and for these to form the basis of useful investigation hypotheses it is not always possible on the basis of a crime scene to provide reliable psychological-based explanations of the behavior of a criminal at that scene. Moreover, the fact of association of various types of physical evidence with offenders in a number of cases does not mean that these same types of evidence can be used to provide proof of a criminal’s guilt in respect of a number of different aspects of an offense including the criminal’s motive. In particular, the processes of source attribution, activity reconstruction, and psychological interpretation provide useful boundary conditions for understanding the provision of criminalistic based observation, competing explanations, predictions and conclusions within evidence constrained framework. Five tables and three figures have been provided in order to facilitate an understanding of the interface of the various disciplinary areas mentioned and in order to provide practical safeguards. In addition, in order to ensure that in the future sufficient validation studies are carried out on any new technique or method of investigation, and that the results obtained are applicable to a number of different cultures, that adequate provision is made for the expression of uncertainty in all investigations, and that contamination of any type of information is prevented, these aspects have been given due priority.

Keywords: Criminal Psychology; Criminology; Forensic Science; Behavioral Evidence; Investigative Interviewing; Cognitive Bias

Citation

Chatterjee S, Chakraborty M. The Criminal Mind Under the Forensic Lens: A Critical Narrative Review of Criminal Psychology, Criminology and Forensic Evidence. WebLog J Forensic Sci Criminol. wjfsc.2026.k0501. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24222938